Exclusive Insurance Leads

ONE LEAD.
ONE AGENT.
NO SPLIT.

PonyLeads sells every lead to exactly one agency — never shared, never resold, never sent to your competitor down the street. Just real, consent-verified prospects who want to talk.

Request Access How It Works
PonyLeads mascot
1
Agent Per Lead
0
Leads Resold
4
Lines Covered
100%
Consent Verified
Why Agencies Work With Us

BUILT FOR AGENTS WHO ARE TIRED OF SHARING

Most lead vendors sell the same prospect to three, four, five agents at once. We built PonyLeads around a simpler rule: once a lead is yours, it's not going anywhere else.

Exclusive, Not Shared

Every lead goes to one agency only. No bidding wars, no five agents calling the same person within the hour.

Compliance Built In

Every lead comes with documented, timestamped consent — built to hold up, not just to convert.

Real-Time Delivery

Leads land in your inbox the moment someone submits — no batching, no next-day dumps.

The Process

THREE STEPS, START TO FIRST LEAD

No contracts to untangle, no minimums that trap you. Tell us what you need and we build around it.

01

Tell us your lines and territory

Home, auto, life, or commercial — and where you write business. We match your funnel to exactly that.

02

We run the funnel, you don't lift a finger

PonyLeads owns the ad spend, the landing pages, and the consent flow. You just wait for the lead to land.

03

Leads land, you call — that's it

Full contact info, quiz answers, and lead priority grade delivered straight to your inbox in real time.

Coverage

FOUR LINES, ONE SOURCE

Personal Lines

Home Insurance

Homeowners actively comparing coverage

Personal Lines

Auto Insurance

Drivers near a renewal or new purchase

Life

Life Insurance

Prospects at real life-event trigger points

Commercial

Commercial Insurance

Small business owners shopping coverage

Pricing

PAY FOR QUALITY, NOT VOLUME

Load a balance, and leads are drawn from it automatically based on grade. No subscriptions, no per-lead invoicing.

Set your expectations

These are high-quality, fully exclusive leads — not cheap shared leads sold to five agents at once. Because of that, they can be more scarce and arrive less frequently than the high-volume, low-cost leads you may be used to. You're trading volume for exclusivity and quality.

A
$80
Highest-intent leads
B
$50
Strong-intent leads
C
$40
Qualified leads
How it works: load a minimum $500 balance. Each lead we deliver is deducted automatically at its grade price. Choose which grades you want to receive below — your balance is only ever spent on the grades you select.

START RECEIVING LEADS

Set up your account below and get on the path to exclusive, high-quality leads for your agency.

  • Exclusive leads, one buyer only
  • Documented consent on every lead
  • No long-term contract required
How the balance works: load at least $500 to get started. Each lead we deliver is deducted automatically at its grade price — $80 for A, $50 for B, $40 for C — based on the grades you selected. There's no expiration and no use-it-or-lose-it pressure. If you ever want to stop, any unused balance in your account can be refunded back to you on request — just reach out and we'll send back whatever hasn't been spent.

You'll be taken straight to a secure payment page to get set up. We verify your license before leads start flowing.

Thanks — redirecting you to payment now.
Support

ALREADY WORKING WITH US?

For existing Agency Customers — questions about a specific lead, billing, or your account.

General Support

Email info@ponyleads.com for account, billing, or delivery questions. We typically respond within 1-2 business days.

Report a Lead Issue

Invalid number, duplicate, or suspected bot submission? Email us within 5 business days of delivery with the lead details — see our refund & dispute policy for what qualifies.